After the bubble comes the recovery. In part 3 of my series on why we’re not in a bubble, you saw how non-distressed homes are taking on a greater role in the market. The final bit of proof that we’re not in a bubble goes like this…

The chart below is from part 1 of our analysis. Recall that the little spike in 2009 (green box in Market Index below) where we saw people taking advantage of the First Time Home-buyer Tax Credit.

And then the banks brought a few more things like foreclosures and short sales on the market, as we were struggling to get out of that. There was a little dip their between 2009 and 2010 in prices and a shot back up. We had a lot of inventory on the market. These are normal home sales people who were up against distressed inventory so they had to bring their prices down.

Distressed only

When we look at distressed-only prices in this next chart, we still have this jump.

 

On the far right of this chart, on top of the horizontal blue line, is where normal (non-distressed) sales prices are at $202, 382.

If you draw back into the past, you run into this green box on the left. Look at where the price lands and to see that it’s not the same. Actually, before that, that price landed in late 2004. It’s a different measure, because the last time we saw the price going up, it was the last quarter of 2006 (the right side of the green box on the left).

The last time we saw prices like our non-distressed number of $202,382 going up was at the end of 2005. The conditions were much different –buyers paid very little down payment, they had little skin in the game, sellers could choose their appraisers and lenders were going mad.

The last time we saw them going down was at the end of 2008. In terms of price increase, distressed home sales still have 45% to go in order to get up to $202,382. But that’s probably not going to happen. Back at the worst of it, distressed homes sales had 102% to go to reach normal.

We’ve come a long way in terms of prices coming up on those distressed homes, so yes, if you can into a distressed home, that’s great, but there are very few of them around.

And this, dear friends, is why were not in a bubble:

• Distressed homes are still pulling prices down.
• Inventory might be tight, but it’s not as tight as you thought it was (we talked about this in part one).
• Distressed property inventory is really tight, but the normal property inventory is growing at a regular pace.
• Normal property prices are still relatively low compared to what we saw before the bubble.
• If those $202,382 prices for normal homes were in the same landscape where we saw the same conditions that were happening pre-bubble (like in the last chart we reviewed in part 2 “Return of the Equity Seller”, with things like 100% financing and the like, I’d say yeah, we’re in a bubble, and we might be really worried.
• We’d be way, way above our long term trend line (part 2) if that was happening.

Where do the voices decrying “We’re in a bubble!” come from?

What does the answer have to do with the coming summer?

That’s next week!

If you want to sell or buy, please give me a call at (602) 456-9388 or email ken@getyourphx.com. I can get it done!